Start with high-confidence christian fantasy books, then narrow by subgenre or adjacent topics.
The Book of the Dun Cow
Walter Wangerin, Jr.
Talon of God
Wesley Snipes, Ray Norman
Broken Angel
Sigmund Brouwer
The Mystic Rose
Stephen R. Lawhead
Moonblood
Anne Elisabeth Stengl
King's Folly
Jill Williamson
King's Blood
King's War
Light of Eidon
Karen Hancock, Adam Verner
Mark of the Raven
Morgan L. Busse
Flight of the Raven
The 49th Mystic
Ted Dekker, Alyssa Bresnahan
Desecration
Tim LaHaye
From Darkness Won
Cyndere's Midnight
Jeffrey Overstreet
Raven's Ladder
The Ale Boy's Feast
The Gift
Bryan Litfin, Bryan M. Litfin
Edge of Eternity
Randy Alcorn
The Last Guardian
Shane Johnson
Hood
Stephen Lawhead
Black
Ted Dekker
The Circle Series 4-in-1
Ted Dekker, Rob Lamont
The Skin Map
Stephen Lawhead, Stephen R. Lawhead
Lilith
George MacDonald, Jonathan St. John
At the Back of the North Wind
George Macdonald
