Start with high-confidence ya supernatural thrillers books, then narrow by subgenre or adjacent topics.
The Body Finder
Kimberly Derting
Clown in a Cornfield
Adam Cesare
White Smoke
Tiffany D. Jackson
Famous Last Words
Katie Alender
The Weaver Bride
Lydia Gregovic
And the River Drags Her Down
Jihyun Yun
What the Woods Took
Courtney Gould
Moonsick
Tom O'Donnell, Tom O'Donnell
The Tenth Girl
Sara Faring
The White Guy Dies First
Terry J. Benton-Walker, Faridah Àbíké-Íyímídé
The Changing Man
Tomi Oyemakinde
Here Lies a Vengeful Bitch
Codie Crowley, Justis Bolding
Rick Riordan Presents: It Lurks in the Night
Sarah Dass
I Dare You
Jeff Ross
Hunt for Eden’s Star
D. J. Williams
The Dead of Summer
Ryan La Sala
The Merciless
Danielle Vega
Crazy Dangerous
Andrew Klavan
A Feast for the Eyes
Alex Crespo
The Taking of Jake Livingston
Ryan Douglass
I Shall Awaken
Katerina Sardicka, Stepanka Coufalova
